Urban-PLUMBER

A multi-site model evaluation project for urban areas

Phase 2 Phase 1 Download project protocol
Mathew Lipson (UNSW), Sue Grimmond (Reading), Martin Best (Met Office),
with observational and modelling participants.

US-Minneapolis1: Manabe_1T

NOTE: Results presented here are highly dependent on how models are configured in this experiment and may be subject to variable output formatting errors. Results are not intended to indicate the quality of any individual model, but to help participants better understand and improve modelling approaches in different urban environments.

Submitted metadata

Error metrics

flux experiment MAE MBE nSD R 5th 95th RMSE cRMSE AMBE 1-nSD 1-R nSkewness nKurtosis Overlap
SWup baseline 42.8415 -42.2516 0.490707 0.8396 1.70287 162.583 75.4586 0.645599 42.2516 0.509294 0.1604 0.616218 1.08811 0.170602
SWup detailed 40.8657 -40.1402 0.506608 0.82627 1.66753 157.199 74.4649 0.647658 40.1402 0.493392 0.17373 0.634155 1.11492 0.154489
LWup baseline 17.4998 16.8915 1.10857 0.982099 17.146 39.4786 23.5782 0.226886 16.8915 0.108573 0.017901 0.978297 0.291964 0.11158
LWup detailed 17.4547 16.8588 1.11966 0.982262 15.7316 40.9671 23.8392 0.232469 16.8588 0.119663 0.0177385 0.995739 0.320788 0.11011
Qle baseline 30.4881 8.39506 0.767235 0.565686 8.03454 26.7384 47.8899 0.848894 8.39506 0.232765 0.434314 0.103944 0.239002 0.35501
Qle detailed 30.2804 8.18717 0.775209 0.567285 7.7062 24.5623 47.8797 0.849365 8.18717 0.224791 0.432715 0.104704 0.246864 0.330919
Qh baseline 36.9871 -1.62306 0.679422 0.797947 14.4167 60.1505 51.6357 0.614271 1.62306 0.320579 0.202053 0.0844089 0.912097 0.323902
Qh detailed 36.0088 -2.85216 0.675057 0.80907 13.2704 63.7191 50.7265 0.602798 2.85216 0.324943 0.19093 0.0607386 0.84237 0.307645
Qg baseline 45.7723 -0.489182 2.04678 0.776833 56.1051 86.5906 63.2939 1.4175 0.489182 1.04676 0.223167 0.323479 0.668021 0.383143
Qg detailed 42.2125 -0.399128 1.94433 0.782819 51.8525 76.4898 58.8368 1.31769 0.399128 0.944312 0.217181 0.333605 0.673887 0.36462
Qtau baseline 0.140674 -0.128543 0.402751 0.867086 0.00939895 0.397593 0.203596 0.681006 0.128543 0.59725 0.132914 0.0160808 0.107885 0.330513
Qtau detailed 0.158597 -0.150115 0.327814 0.865952 0.00683428 0.45376 0.227035 0.734656 0.150115 0.672186 0.134048 0.0124878 0.0630364 0.38448
SoilTemp baseline 2.23333 -1.1345 1.18862 0.982386 5.91656 1.48944 3.14938 0.278297 1.1345 0.188624 0.0176143 4.12398 0.141853 0.208643
SoilTemp detailed 2.21235 -1.18415 1.16945 0.983656 5.36501 1.18283 2.97697 0.258724 1.18415 0.169455 0.0163437 3.30666 0.0949158 0.195112

Link to variable definitions

subset_SWup_v0-9

Manabe_1T_US-Minneapolis1_subset_SWup_v0-9.png

out of range: baseline

out of range: detailed

Link to variable definitions